DevOps and Scrum are two distinct but complementary approaches in the world of software development and IT. They both aim to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the development process, but they focus on different aspects and have different methodologies and goals.
In this blog post we will explore some of the differences between DevOps and Scrum.
- The DevOps Scrum Master: A Convergence Of Agile And Operational Excellence
- 15 Top DevOps Skills In 2024
- The 2024 DevOps Roadmap: How To Become A DevOps Engineer In 8 Steps
Focus and Purpose
In the realm of software development methodologies, DevOps and Scrum stand out as two distinctive approaches, each with its unique focus and purpose. DevOps, short for Development and Operations, places its emphasis on fostering collaboration and communication between development and operations teams. Its overarching objective is to revolutionize the software delivery process by automating and streamlining the flow of deployments and operations, ultimately resulting in faster and more reliable software releases.
Conversely, Scrum takes a different route as a project management framework. It zeroes in on optimizing how development teams collaborate to deliver tangible value through shippable increments of a product. Unlike DevOps, Scrum places its primary focus on the orchestration and management of the software development process itself. While deployment and operations are essential aspects of any software project, Scrum's main concern is with the teamwork and processes leading up to these critical phases.
In a real-world scenario where a company is building an e-commerce platform, a DevOps team would set up automated pipelines to quickly deploy new features to production. Meanwhile, a Scrum team would divide the project into two-week Sprints, concentrating on completing a specific set of high-priority features within that time frame. While the DevOps team is busy fine-tuning auto-scaling for holiday traffic, the Scrum team holds a review to demonstrate the newly developed search functionality to stakeholders.
Essentially, DevOps ensures the platform runs smoothly at all times, whereas Scrum ensures the platform meets user needs incrementally.
DevOps is not merely a methodology; it's a cultural and technical movement that reshapes how development and operations teams collaborate. It champions principles such as continuous integration, continuous delivery (CI/CD), automation, and above all, fostering a culture of collaboration. DevOps seeks to dissolve traditional barriers between development and operations, emphasizing the need for seamless communication and cooperation. The end goal is faster and more efficient software deployment.
In contrast, Scrum is a well-defined agile framework designed to provide structure to the software development process. It introduces specific roles such as Scrum Master, Product Owner, and Development Team, each with well-defined responsibilities. Key events, including Sprints, Daily Standups, Sprint Reviews, and Sprint Retrospectives, ensure a structured approach. Scrum also brings essential artifacts like the Product Backlog, Sprint Backlog, and Increment into play, enhancing transparency and productivity.
Picture a mid-sized e-commerce company, "ShopEase," specializing in smart home devices. For years, they had faithfully followed a Scrum framework—featuring a Scrum Master named Sarah, a Product Owner named Tim, and a Development Team led by Alex. They executed two-week Sprints, Daily Standups, and maintained a Product Backlog that Tim prioritized. Despite their best efforts, software deployments often lagged, creating tension between the development team and the operations team led by Olivia, who were responsible for maintaining the online storefront.
Recognizing the need for a more collaborative and efficient process, ShopEase decided to integrate DevOps principles into their existing Scrum framework. A cross-functional team was created, including members from both Alex's development team and Olivia's operations team. They implemented a continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD) pipeline, using Jenkins for automation and Kubernetes for container orchestration. Automated testing was rolled out, using Selenium for front-end tests and JUnit for back-end tests.
Within the first three months, the cultural shift was palpable. Alex and Olivia found themselves in regular sync, exchanging crucial information that helped both sides understand the lifecycle of the product. The implementation of automation and CI/CD pipelines drastically reduced manual errors and accelerated deployment times.
The end result? ShopEase saw a 30% reduction in time-to-market for new features and a significant improvement in site reliability. What's more, the transparent and cooperative environment fostered by the fusion of DevOps and Scrum principles led to higher job satisfaction scores across both development and operations teams.
Teams and Roles
When it comes to organizing teams and defining roles, DevOps and Scrum take notably different approaches.
DevOps places a strong emphasis on breaking down the traditional silos that often separate development and operations teams. In the DevOps philosophy, there are no specific, predefined DevOps team structure. Instead, DevOps encourages individuals from both the development and operations teams to work collaboratively and collectively. This collaborative mindset ensures that everyone involved shares responsibilities and works together towards the common goal of smoother and more efficient software delivery.
In contrast, Scrum provides a well-structured framework with specific roles designed to optimize the development process. The key roles in Scrum include the Scrum Master, who acts as a facilitator and servant leader, ensuring that the Scrum framework is followed effectively. The Product Owner takes charge of managing the product backlog, aligning development efforts with business goals. Lastly, the Development Team is a cross-functional group comprising developers, testers, and other specialists necessary for product development. Each role has well-defined responsibilities within the Scrum framework, contributing to the clarity and organization of the development process.
Consider a fintech startup, "FinTrust," that initially chose to implement the Scrum framework for its mobile application development. They had clear roles: Emily was the Scrum Master, responsible for ensuring Scrum practices were followed. Robert, the Product Owner, managed the product backlog and prioritized features based on business value. The Development Team, led by software engineer Jenna, comprised back-end and front-end developers, a QA specialist, and a UI/UX designer. Each member had well-defined responsibilities, and the team followed a two-week Sprint cycle that included Daily Standups and Sprint Retrospectives.
However, as the FinTrust app gained traction, they realized they needed to speed up the deployment process and improve coordination between the development team and the operations team responsible for server maintenance and security, led by Marcus. A decision was made to shift towards a DevOps model to complement their existing Scrum approach. Now, instead of working in isolation, Jenna's development team and Marcus's operations team began to operate as a unified DevOps unit. They collectively worked on building and deploying code, and shared responsibilities for monitoring and incident management.
To facilitate this new collaborative culture, the company set up shared communication channels and integrated tools like GitHub for version control, Docker for containerization, and Terraform for infrastructure as code. They started using a shared dashboard that displayed real-time metrics related to system performance, error rates, and deployment timelines. Everyone, regardless of their original "side" of development or operations, had access and contributed to this shared pool of information.
The impact was significant. The once rigid structure transformed into a flexible, efficient, and highly collaborative environment. FinTrust's software deployments were faster, and incidents were resolved more efficiently due to the collective expertise of the unified team. The structured roles in Scrum provided the discipline needed for software development, while the collaborative ethos of DevOps ensured a seamless and efficient delivery pipeline. Both systems, together, enhanced FinTrust's ability to deliver a robust, secure, and user-friendly mobile application.
DevOps operates in a way that is not confined by specific time frames or fixed iterations. Instead, it places a strong emphasis on continuous improvement and delivery. DevOps teams work to create a culture of ongoing refinement and enhancement, with the ultimate goal of achieving more efficient and reliable software delivery processes.
In contrast, Scrum is known for its structured approach to time management. It operates within fixed-length time boxes referred to as "Sprints." These Sprints typically span from 2 to 4 weeks, providing a clear and predetermined time frame for each phase of development. At the end of each Sprint, the goal is to deliver a potentially shippable product increment, ensuring regular and tangible progress within a defined time frame.
Let's examine "EduCare," a company specializing in online educational software for K-12 schools. They initially used a Scrum approach to manage their development cycle. Michelle, the Scrum Master, facilitated two-week Sprints, along with regular ceremonies like Daily Standups and Sprint Retrospectives. Craig, the Product Owner, had a product backlog that aimed for potentially shippable increments at the end of each Sprint. Their Development Team included software engineers, a database administrator, and a QA tester.
However, as EduCare's customer base grew, the limitations of a strict time-boxed approach became apparent. They needed to rapidly roll out security patches, adapt to fluctuating server loads due to growing user numbers, and implement urgent feature requests from educators. To address these demands, EduCare decided to supplement their Scrum approach with DevOps practices.
Tara, who led the operations team, coordinated with Michelle and Craig to blend DevOps' continuous improvement philosophy into their existing framework. They introduced tools like GitLab for version control and CI/CD pipelines, Ansible for automation, and Prometheus for monitoring. The goal was to achieve a constant state of readiness, allowing them to deploy new features or patches at any time, rather than waiting for the end of a Sprint.
With the DevOps mindset embedded into their workflow, EduCare was no longer confined to the rigid time frames dictated by Sprints. They could now deploy urgent updates in a matter of hours, not weeks. Moreover, the operations and development teams began to function as a cohesive unit, continually refining and enhancing their procedures. This collaboration resulted in quicker incident resolution and an overall more reliable and efficient software delivery process.
In this blended approach, the structure of Scrum kept the team focused and aligned with business objectives, while the agility of DevOps allowed them to adapt to real-time demands and continuously optimize their processes. EduCare successfully married the best of both worlds, achieving both discipline and flexibility in their software delivery.
DevOps casts a broader net when it comes to deliverables. Its primary concern extends across the entire software delivery pipeline. This includes tasks such as infrastructure provisioning, automating deployment processes, implementing robust monitoring solutions, and establishing effective feedback loops. The overarching objective of DevOps is to optimize the end-to-end process, ensuring that software is not only developed efficiently but also seamlessly delivered and maintained in production.
In contrast, Scrum's focus is primarily on the product itself. It aims to deliver functional increments of the product during each Sprint. A Sprint is a time-bound iteration lasting typically from 2 to 4 weeks, and at the end of each Sprint, the goal is to have a potentially shippable product increment. Scrum ensures that the product is continuously refined and improved in a structured manner, prioritizing the delivery of valuable features.
Consider "Healthlytics," a healthcare analytics company that uses advanced machine learning algorithms to predict patient outcomes. Initially, they employed a Scrum framework for product development. Their Scrum Master, Vanessa, worked closely with Neil, the Product Owner, to prioritize features for their analytics platform in the Product Backlog. Their Development Team, headed by Carla, diligently worked in three-week Sprints to deliver functional increments of the product.
While Scrum helped them churn out feature-rich updates, they faced challenges in deployment, monitoring, and scaling. This is where Dave, who led the operations team, felt a broader view was essential. Healthlytics decided to adopt DevOps practices to extend their focus beyond just product features to the entire software delivery pipeline.
A collaborative DevOps team was formed, pulling in experts from Carla's Development Team and Dave's Operations Team. Together, they adopted tools like Terraform for infrastructure provisioning, Jenkins for automating deployment processes, and Grafana for robust monitoring solutions. With the integration of these tools, they were able to oversee the end-to-end software delivery process, from code commits to deployment in production, and even post-deployment monitoring.
The benefits of this wider focus became evident quickly. Deployment times reduced by 40%, and the feedback loop with the customer support and analytics departments was tighter, thanks to real-time monitoring and automated alerts. When a problem was detected, whether it was a bug or a resource constraint, it was now dealt with swiftly and efficiently. This extended focus ensured that Healthlytics was not just shipping features rapidly, but also maintaining a stable and efficient production environment.
By broadening their view to embrace DevOps principles, Healthlytics optimized their entire delivery pipeline, complementing the feature-focused, structured approach provided by Scrum. The end result was a more resilient, efficient, and customer-centric analytics platform, satisfying both their internal teams and their healthcare clients.
DevOps is a methodology that leans heavily on automation and technology. It thrives on the use of specialized tools to streamline various aspects of the software development and deployment process. Commonly employed DevOps tools include Jenkins, Docker, Kubernetes, and various monitoring solutions. These tools play critical roles in automating code integration, testing, deployment, and continuous monitoring, enabling DevOps teams to achieve greater efficiency and reliability.
Unlike DevOps, Scrum is not prescriptive when it comes to specific tools. Instead, Scrum focuses on practices and roles within the agile framework. Nevertheless, many Scrum teams leverage project management and collaboration tools such as Jira and Trello to facilitate the Scrum processes. These tools help Scrum teams manage tasks, track progress, and ensure effective communication and collaboration among team members.
Imagine "StreamLife," a company specializing in streaming services for independent films and documentaries. Initially, their development process was primarily based on Scrum. Susan, the Scrum Master, facilitated the agile ceremonies, while Mark, the Product Owner, managed the product backlog. The Development Team, led by Amit, worked in four-week Sprints to develop new features and functionalities. To help manage their Scrum activities, they utilized Jira for backlog management and Sprint tracking, as well as Slack for team communication.
As StreamLife's user base started to expand, they began facing challenges in deployment scalability, reliability, and speed. That's when they realized the need for a more technology-centric approach. They decided to incorporate DevOps into their workflow to focus on automation and efficiency in their software development and deployment processes.
Enter Lisa, the head of the operations team, who collaborated with Amit to form a cohesive DevOps team. They started using Jenkins for continuous integration, automating the build and test phases. Docker containers were employed to create consistent development environments, and Kubernetes helped them scale these containers for production. For continuous monitoring, they integrated Grafana and Prometheus, enabling them to keep a close eye on system performance and potential issues.
The introduction of these specialized DevOps tools revolutionized StreamLife's workflow. Automation reduced human errors and expedited deployment, allowing for several deployments per day as opposed to a few per Sprint. The DevOps methodology, with its emphasis on technology and automation, brought about greater efficiency and reliability, aligning well with the structured, role-based approach of Scrum that they had in place.
In the end, StreamLife managed to maintain the strengths of their Scrum framework—such as clear roles, structured development, and business-aligned priorities—while also harnessing the power of automation and technology that DevOps offers. This hybrid approach provided StreamLife the best of both worlds: the agility and focus of Scrum, along with the efficiency and technological prowess of DevOps.
▶ Key Insight
This article is titled DevOps VS Scrum, but their doesn't need to be an adversarial relationship between DevOps and Scrum methodologies.
These two approaches can compliment each other if you take the best of both and incorporate them into a singular delivery methodology. I believe that the key to delivery is setting yourself up for success early by promoting quality and value as the key pillars for success. How you get there is totally up to you, but there is never a "right" way to do anything.
Make sure your approach on deliver is focused on people and how people are comfortable delivering quality and value first and you will find great successes on your journey.
While DevOps and Scrum share some common goals, they operate at different levels within the software development and delivery process. DevOps focuses on the entire software delivery pipeline and encourages collaboration between development and operations, whereas Scrum is a project management framework that defines roles, events, and artifacts to manage the development process within fixed time frames. Many organizations adopt both DevOps and Scrum practices to optimize their software development and delivery processes.